If we receive a monitor event from a forwarded-to channel which
contains a preimage for an HTLC, we have to propogate that preimage
back to the forwarded-from channel monitor. However, once we have
that update, we're running in a relatively unsafe state - we have
the preimage in memory, but if we were to crash the forwarded-to
channel monitor will not regenerate the update with the preimage
for us. If we haven't managed to write the monitor update to the
forwarded-from channel by that point, we've lost the preimage, and,
thus, money!
When a `chain::Watch` `ChannelMonitor` update method is called, the
user has three options:
(a) persist the monitor update immediately and return success,
(b) fail to persist the monitor update immediately and return
failure,
(c) return a flag indicating the monitor update is in progress and
will complete in the future.
(c) is rather harmless, and in some deployments should be expected
to be the return value for all monitor update calls, but currently
requires returning `Err(ChannelMonitorUpdateErr::TemporaryFailure)`
which isn't very descriptive and sounds scarier than it is.
Instead, here, we change the return type used to be a single enum
(rather than a Result) and rename `TemporaryFailure`
`UpdateInProgress`.
See doc updates for more info on the edge case this prevents, and
there isn't really a strong reason why we would need to broadcast
the latest state immediately. Specifically, in the case of HTLC
claims (the most important reason to ensure we have state on chain
if it cannot be persisted), we will still force-close if there are
HTLCs which need claiming and are going to expire.
Surprisingly, there were no tests which failed as a result of this
change, but a new one has been added.
Now that the features contexts track the full set of all known
features, rather than the set of supported features, all defined
features should be listed in the context definition macro.
This adds a compile-time assertion to check that all bits for known
features are set in the context known set.
Now that the `*Features::known` constructor has been removed, there
is no reason to define feature bits as either optional required in
`features.rs` - that logic now belongs in the modules that are
responsible for the given features.
Instead, we only list all features in each context.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we (finally) remove the `known` constructor entirely,
modifying tests in the `features` module as required.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
In anticipation of removing the `known` constructor, this commit
removes all remaining references to it outside of features.rs.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we stop relying on the `known` method in our fuzz tests.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we stop relying on the `known` method in the
`lightning-background-processor` and `lightning-persister` crate
tests.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we stop relying on the `known` method in the
`lightning-net-tokio` crate.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we stop relying on the `known` method in the
`lightning-invoice` crate.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we stop relying on the `known` method in the channel modules.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we stop relying on the `known` method in the
functional_test_utils module.
As we move towards specify supported/required feature bits in the
module(s) where they are supported, the global `known` feature set
constructors no longer make sense.
Here we stop relying on the `known` method in the `routing` module,
which was only used in tests.
Historically, LDK has considered the "set of known/supported
feature bits" to be an LDK-level thing. Increasingly this doesn't
make sense - different message handlers may provide or require
different feature sets.
In a previous PR, we began the process of transitioning with
feature bits sent to peers being sourced from the attached message
handler.
This commit makes further progress by moving the concept of which
feature bits are supported by our ChannelManager into
channelmanager.rs itself, via the new `provided_*_features`
methods, rather than in features.rs via the `known_channel_features`
and `known` methods.
Each test featuring HTLCs had a minimum and maximum feerate case. This
is no longer necessary for the zero HTLC transaction anchors variant as
the commitment feerate does not impact whether HTLCs can be trimmed or
not, only the dust limit does.
With the zero fee HTLC transaction anchors variant, HTLCs can no longer
be trimmed due to their amount being too low to have a mempool valid
HTLC transaction. Now they can only be trimmed based on the dust limit
of each party within the channel.
HTLC transactions from anchor channels are constrained by a CSV of 1
block, so broadcasting them along with the unconfirmed commitment
tranasction will result in them being immediately rejected as premature.
There's no need to broadcast our local commitment transaction if we've
already seen a confirmed one as it'll be immediately rejected as a
duplicate/conflict.
This will also help prevent dispatching spurious events for bumping
commitment and HTLC transactions through anchor outputs (once
implemented in future work) and the dispatch for said events follows the
same flow as our usual commitment broadcast.
Expand the BlockSource trait to allow filtered blocks now that
chain::Listen supports them (d629a7edb7).
This makes it possible to use BIP 157/158 compact block filters with
lightning-block-sync.
As we remove the concept of a global "known/supported" feature set
in LDK, we should also remove the concept of a global "required"
feature set. This does so by moving the checks for specific
required features into handlers.
Specifically, it allows the handler `peer_connected` method to
return an `Err` if the peer should be disconnected. Only one such
required feature bit is currently set - `static_remote_key`, which
is required in `ChannelManager`.
In the next commit we'll enforce counterparty `InitFeatures`
matching our required set in `ChannelManager`, implying they must
be set for many tests where they previously did not need to be (as
they were enforced in `PeerManager`, which is not used in
functional tests).
Currently we entirely ignore the BADONION bit when deciding how to
handle HTLC failures. This opens us up to an attack where a
malicious node always fails HTLCs backwards via
`update_fail_malformed_htlc` with an error code of
`BADONION|NODE|PERM|X`. In this case, we may decide to interpret
this as a permanent node failure for the node encrypting the onion,
i.e. the counterparty of the node who sent the
`update_fail_malformed_htlc` message and ultimately failed the
HTLC.
Thus, any node we route through could cause us to fully remove its
counterparty from our network graph. Luckily we do not do any
persistent tracking of removed nodes, and thus will re-add the
removed node once it is re-announced or on restart, however we are
likely to add such persistent tracking (at least in-memory) in the
future.
