Instead of adding signatures to LocalCommitmentTransactions, we
instead leave them unsigned and use them to construct signed
Transactions when we want them. This cleans up the guts of
LocalCommitmentTransaction enough that we can, and do, expose its
state to the world, allowing external signers to have a basic
awareness of what they're signing.
1107ab06c3 introduced an API to have a
ChannelKeys implementer sign HTLC transactions by calling into the
LocalCommitmentTransaction object, which would then store the tx.
This API was incredibly awkward, both because it required an
external signer trust our own internal interfaces, but also because
it didn't allow for any inspection of what was about to be signed.
Further, it signed the HTLC transactions one-by-one in a somewhat
inefficient way, and there isn't a clear way to resolve this (as
the which-HTLC parameter has to refer to something in between the
HTLC's arbitrary index, and its index in the commitment tx, which
has "holes" for the non-HTLC outputs and skips some HTLCs).
We replace it with a new function in ChannelKeys which allows us
to sign all HTLCs in a given commitment transaction (which allows
for a bit more effeciency on the signers' part, as well as
sidesteps the which-HTLC issue). This may also simplify the signer
implementation as we will always want to sign all HTLCs spending a
given commitment transaction at once anyway.
We also de-mut the LocalCommitmentTransaction passed to the
ChanKeys, instead opting to make LocalCommitmentTransaction const
and avoid storing any new HTLC-related data in it.
This cleans up sign_local_commitment somewhat by returning a
Result<Signaure, ()> over the local commitment transaction instead
of modifying the struct which was passed in.
This is the first step in making LocalCommitmentTransaction a
completely pub struct, using it just to communicate enough
information to the user to allow them to construct a signaure
instead of having it contain a bunch of logic.
This should make it much easier to implement a custom ChannelKeys
by disconnecting the local commitment transaction signing from our
own datastructures.
In e46e183084 we began tracking
whether a local commitment transaction had been signed and
broadcast in OnchainTxHandler, refusing to update the local
commitment transaction state in the ChannelMonitor on that basis.
This is fine, except that it doesn't make a lot of sense to store
the full local transaction state in OnchainTxHandler - we should be
providing it the unsigned local transaction at the time we wish to
broadcast and no more (just like we do all other transaction data).
As channel_value last usage was for computing feerate but as this
one is static per-commitment and will always-be following specification,
we remove it.
We want to avoid a third-party channel closure, where a random node
by sending us a payment expiring at current height, would trigger our
onchain logic to close the channel due to a near-expiration.
Relatively simple test that, after a monitor update fails, we get
the right return value and continue with the bits of the MPP that
did not send after the monitor updating is restored.
This is a key test for our automatic HTLC time-out logic, as it
ensures we don't allow an HTLC which indicates we should wait for
additional HTLCs before responding to cause us to force-close a
channel due to HTLC near-timeout.
expect_payment_failed!() was introduced after many of the tests
which could use it were written, so we take this opportunity to
switch them over now, increasing test coverage slightly by always
checking the payment hash expected.
We only do this for incoming HTLCs directly as we rely on channel
closure and HTLC-Timeout broadcast to fail any HTLCs which we
relayed onwards where our next-hop doesn't update_fail in time.
Since we now are always initialised with an initial local commitment
transaction available now, we might as well take advantage of it and
stop using an Option<> where we don't need to.
Previously, we created the initial ChannelMonitor on outbound
channels when we generated the funding_created message. This was
somewhat unnecessary as, at that time, we hadn't yet received
clearance to broadcast our initial funding transaction, and thus
there should never be any use for a ChannelMonitor. It also
complicated ChannelMonitor a bit as, at this point, we didn't have
an initial local commitment transaction.
By moving the creation of the initial ChannelMonitor to when we
receive our counterparty's funding_signed, we can ensure that any
ChannelMonitor will always have both a latest remote commitment tx
and a latest local commitment tx for broadcast.
This also fixes a strange API where we would close a channel
unceremoniously on peer-disconnection if we hadn't yet received the
funding_signed, but we'd already have a ChannelMonitor for that
channel. While it isn't strictly a bug (some potential DoS issues
aside), it is strange that these two definitions of a channel being
open were not in sync.
1107ab06c3 introduced some additional
metadata, including per-HTLC data in LocalCommitmentTransaction. To
keep diff reasonable it did so in ChannelMonitor after the
LocalCommitmentTransaction had been constructed and passed over the
wall, but there's little reason to do so - we should just be
constructing them with the data from the start, filled in by Channel.
This cleans up some internal interfaces a bit, slightly reduces
some data duplication and moves us one step forward to exposing
the guts of LocalCommitmentTransaction publicly in a sensible way.
The ChanKeys is created with knowledge of the Channel's value and
funding redeemscript up-front, so we should not be providing it
when making signing requests.
3d640da5c3 looped over a new HashMap
new_claims, clone()ing entries out of it right before droppng the
whole thing. This is an obvious candidate for drain(..).
Not only was watchtower mode never implemented, but the bits that
we had were removed some time ago. It doesn't seem likely we'll
move forward with a "watchtower-mode" ChannelMonitor, instead
we'll likely have some other, separate struct for this.
`incorrect_or_unknown_payment_details` failure message,
`0x4000 (PERM) | 15`, should include the following data:
- [u64:htlc_msat]
- [u32:height]
This patches ensure that the height is included in all
the occurrences of this failure message.
After we moved the ChannelMonitor creation later during Channel
init, we never went back and cleaned up ChannelMonitor to remove
a number of now-useless Option<>s, so we do that now.
1107ab06c3 added a Vec of future
updates to apply during a loop, fixing a borrow checker issue that
didn't exist in the merged version of the patch. This simply reverts
that small part of the change.
The new OnchainDetection struct (which is the remnants of the old
KeyStorage enum, which was removed in 1dbda4faed)
doesn't really add any clarity to ChannelMonitor, so best to just
drop it and move its members into ChannelMonitor directly.
This test tries the new lockdown logic in case of a signed-and-broadcast
local commitment transaction while a concurrent ChannelMonitorUpdate for
a next _local_ commitment is submitted from offchain. Update is rejected
as expected with a ChannelMonitorUpdateErr.
Channel shouldn't send a ChannelForceClosed update followed by
a LatestLocalCommitmentTxInfo as it would be a programming error
leading to risk of money loss. Force-closing the channel will
broadcast the local commitment transaction, if the revocation
secret for this one is released after its broadcast, it would
allow remote party to claim outputs on this transaction using
the revocation path.
Local commitment transaction broadcast can be triggered by a)
a Channel force-close or b) reaching some block height implying
a onchain HTLC-timeout. If one of this condition is fulfilled,
commitment is signed and from then any state update would be
rejected.
ChannelMonitor init at Channel creation need to be refactored
before to make get_fully_signed_local_tx infaillible to avoid
choking in the test framework.
HTLC Transaction can't be bumped without sighash changes
so their gneeration is one-time for nwo. We move them in
OnchainTxHandler for simplifying ChannelMonitor and to prepare
storage of keys material behind one external signer interface.
Some tests break due to change in transaction broadcaster order.
Number of transactions may vary because of temporary anti-duplicata
tweak can't dissociate between 2- broadcast from different
origins (ChannelMonitor, ChannelManager) and 2-broadcast from same
component.
In case of channel force-closure, access to local commitment
transactions and its dependent HTLCs is needed. Instead of using
broadcast_by_local_state which registers outpoint to claim and
outputs to watch which are going to be discarded in this case,
we simply ask OnchainTxHandler to build and sign HTLC transactions
through new API.
Splitting further parsing from transaction generation, we cache
transaction elements needed for local HTLC transaction inside
OnchainTxHandler. Duplicated data will be removed from ChannelMonitor
in future commits.
Splitting further parsing from transaction generation, we cache
transaction elements needed for local HTLC transaction inside
OnchainTxHandler. Duplicated data will be removed from ChannelMonitor
in future commits.
Extend external signer interface to sign HTLC transactions on its
behalf without seckey passing. This move will allow us to remove
key access access from ChannelMonitor hot memory in further work.
HTLC transactions should stay half-signed by remote until
we need to broadcast them for timing-out/claiming HTLCs onchain.
Caching of input material for HTLC transaction was introducted
prevently but since then API (InputMaterial) has changed
between ChannelMonitor and OnchainTxHandler
