We remove test_no_failure_dust_htlc_local_commitment from our test
framework as this test deliberately throwing junk transaction in
our monitoring parsing code is hitting new assertions.
This test was added in #333, but it sounds as an oversight as the
correctness intention of this test (i.e verifying lack of dust
HTLCs canceling back in case of junk commitment transaction) doesn't
currently break.
This test is a mutation to underscore the detetection logic bug
we had before #653. HTLC value routed is above the remaining
balance, thus inverting HTLC and `to_remote` output. HTLC
will come second and it wouldn't be seen by pre-#653 detection
as we were eneumerate()'ing on a watched outputs vector (Vec<TxOut>)
thus implictly relying on outputs order detection for correct
spending children filtering.
Previously, outputs were monitored based on txid and an index yelled
from an enumeration over the returned selected outputs by monitoring
code. This is always have been broken but was only discovered while
introducing anchor outputs as those ones rank always first per BIP69.
We didn't have test cases where a HTLC was bigger than a party balance
on a holder commitment and thus not ranking first.
Next commit introduce test coverage.
In review of the final doc changes in #649, I noticed there
appeared to be redundant monitored-outpoints function in
`ChannelMonitor` - `get_monitored_outpoints()` and
`get_outputs_to_watch()`.
In 6f08779b04,
get_monitored_outpoints() was added, with its behavior largely the
same as today's - only returning the set of remote commitment txn
outputs that we've learned about on-chain. This is clearly not
sufficient, and in 73dce207dd,
`get_outputs_to_watch` was added which was overly cautious to
ensure nothing was missed. Still, the author of 73dce207dd
(me) seemed entirely unaware of the work in 6f08779b04
(also me), despite the function being the literal next function in
the same file. This is presumably because it was assumed that
`get_monitored_outpoints` referred to oupoints for which we should
monitor for spends of (which is true), while `get_outputs_to_watch`
referred to outpouts which we should monitor for the transaction
containing said output (which is not true), or something of that
nature. Specifically, it is the expected behavior that the only
time we care about `Filter::register_tx` is for the funding
transaction (which we aren't aware of the inputs of), but for all
other transactions we register interest on the basis of an outpoint
in the previous transaction (ie via `Filter::register_output`).
Here we drop the broken-on-day-one `get_monitored_outpoints()`
version, but assert in testing that the values which it would return
are all present in `get_outputs_to_watch()`.
This also pays a fee on the transactions we generate in response to
SpendableOutputDescriptors in tests.
This fixes the known issues in #630, though we should test for
standardness in other ways as well.
This resolves a number of bugs around how we calculate feerates on
closing transactions:
* We previously calculated the weight wrong both by always
counting two outputs instead of counting the number of outputs
that actually exist in the closing transaction and by not
counting the witness redeemscript.
* We use assertions to check the calculated weight matches what we
actually build (with debug_assertions for variable-length sigs).
* As an additional sanity check, we really should check that the
transaction had at least min-relay-fee when we were the channel
initator.
It was noticed (via clippy) by @casey that we were taking and then
immediately dropping the total_consistency_lock because `let _ =`
doesn't actually bind the response to anything. This appears to be
a consequence of wanting `if let Some(_) =` to not hold a ref to
the contained value at all, but is relatively surprising to me.
Previously, we had a concept of "rescaning" blocks when we detected
a need to monitor for a new set of outputs in future blocks while
connecting a block. In such cases, we'd need to possibly learn about
these new spends later in the *same block*, requiring clients who
filter blocks to get a newly-filtered copy of the same block. While
redoing the chain access API, it became increasingly clear this was
an overly complicated API feature, and it seems likely most clients
will not use it anyway.
Further, any client who *does* filter blocks can simply update their
filtering algorithm to include any descendants of matched
transactions in the filter results, avoiding the need for rescan
support entirely.
Thus, it was decided that we'd move forward without rescan support
in #649, however to avoid significant further changes in the
already-large 649, we decided to fully remove support in a
follow-up.
Here, we remove the API features that existed for rescan and fix
the few tests to not rely on it.
After this commit, we now only ever have one possible version of
block connection transactions, making it possible to be
significantly more confident in our test coverage actually
capturing all realistic scenarios.
Given the chain::Watch interface is defined in terms of ChannelMonitor
and ChannelMonitorUpdateErr, move channelmonitor.rs from the ln module
to the chain module.
Transaction data from a block may be filtered before it is passed to
block_connected functions, which may need the index of each transaction
within the block. Rather than define each function in terms of a slice
of tuples, define a type alias for the slice where it can be documented.
Outputs to watch are tracked by ChannelMonitor as of
73dce207dd. Instead of determining new
outputs to watch independently using ChainWatchedUtil, do so by
comparing against outputs already tracked. Thus, ChainWatchedUtil and
WatchEvent are no longer needed.
WatchEventProvider served as a means for replacing ChainWatchInterface.
However, it requires users to explicitly fetch WatchEvents, even if not
interested in them. Replace WatchEventProvider by chain::Filter, which
is an optional member of ChainMonitor. If set, interesting transactions
and output spends are registered such that blocks containing them can be
retrieved from a chain source in an efficient manner.
This is useful when the chain source is not a full node. For Electrum,
it allows for pre-filtered blocks. For BIP157/158, it serves as a means
to match against compact filters.
BlockNotifier was removed in the previous commit, thus ChainListener is
no longer needed. Instead, anything needing chain events should be
notified directly.
BlockNotifier is a convenience for handing blocks to listeners. However,
it requires that each listener conforms to the ChainListener interface.
Additionally, there are only two listeners, ChannelManager and
ChainMonitor, the latter of which may not be used when monitoring
channels remotely. Remove BlockNotifier since it doesn't provide much
value and constrains each listener to a specific interface.
ChainMonitor's template Key parameter was meant to allow supporting
both local monitoring, where Key=OutPoint, and watchtowers, where Key=
(PublicKey, u32). Use OutPoint directly since the watchtower case will
not be supported this way.
ManyChannelMonitor was renamed chain::Watch in the previous commit. Use
a more concise name for an implementation that monitors the chain for
channel activity. Future work will parameterize the struct to allow for
different varieties of persistence. Thus, users usually will be able to
use ChainMonitor directly rather than implementing a chain::Watch that
wraps it.
Rename ManyChannelMonitor to chain::Watch and move to chain/mod.rs,
where chain-related interfaces live. Update the documentation for
clarity and to conform to rustdoc formatting.
ChainWatchInterface was intended as an interface for watching rather
than accessing the chain. Remove get_chain_utxo and add chain::Access
trait for this behavior. Wrap it with an Option in NetGraphMsgHandler in
order to simplify the error interface.
Use of ChainWatchInterface was replaced with WatchEvent in the previous
commit. Remove it from the parameterization of SimpleManyChannelMonitor
since it is no longer needed.
SimpleManyChannelMonitor is parameterized by ChainWatchInterface to
signal what transactions and outputs to watch for on chain. The
interface has grown to cover chain access (via get_chain_utxo) and block
block filtering (via filter_block and reentered), which has added
complexity for implementations and user (see ChainWatchInterfaceUtil).
Pull the watch functionality out as a first step to eliminating
ChainWatchInterface entirely.
Replace direct uses of BlockNotifier in functional tests with utility
functions. This is in preparation for signaling watch events back via a
refactoring of ManyChannelMonitor and ChainWatchInterface. Those events
will be processed by connect_block.
Change confirm_transaction and connect_blocks to take a Node instead of
a BlockNotifier. This is in preparation for signaling watch events back
via a refactoring of ManyChannelMonitor and ChainWatchInterface.
Use a simple ChainListner implementation rather than large test objects
for testing BlockNotifier.
Remove unregister_single_listener_ref_test since it is redundant with
unregister_single_listener_test.
Remove unnecessary clone() calls.
ChannelMonitor has block_connected and block_disconnected methods called
by <SimpleManyChannelMonitor as ChainListener>. Use similar parameters
in ChannelMonitor such that transformations are not needed and the
interface is more closely aligned with ChainListener.
ChainListeners should be independent of each other, but in practice this
is not the case because ChainWatchInterface introduces a dependency
between them. Push ChainWatchInterface down into the ChainListener
implementations where needed. Update ChainListener's block_connected
method to take a slice of the form &[(usize, &Transaction)] where each
transaction is paired with its position within the block.
In anticipation for removing support for users calling
block_connected multiple times for the same block to include all
relevant transactions in the next PR, this commit stops testing
such cases. Specifically, users who filter blocks for relevant
transactions before calling block_connected will need to filter by
including any transactions which spend a previously-matched
transaction in the same block (and we now do so in our own
filtering logic, which is also used in our testing).
Add a few comments to make it clear whats going on a bit more and
assert the basic structure of more transactions.
Further, point out where transactions are double-spends and don't
confirm double-spends.
We'd previously largely not turned on derive(Debug) on any of our
structs, but not for good reason. Especially for Events objects,
Debug can be a very useful for users to quickly print what they
received from us without having to write out a large match.
* Channel::get_counterparty_htlc_minimum_msat() returned
holder_htlc_minimum_msat, which was obviously incorrect.
* ChannelManager::get_channel_update set htlc_minimum_msat to
Channel::get_holder_htlc_minimum_msat(), but the spec explicitly
states we "MUST set htlc_minimum_msat to the minimum HTLC value
(in millisatoshi) that the channel peer will accept." This makes
sense because the reason we're rejecting the HTLC is because our
counterparty's HTLC minimum value is too small for us to send to
them, our own HTLC minimum value plays no role. Further, our
router already expects this - looking at the same directional
channel info as it does fees.
Finally, we add a test in the existing onion router test cases
which fails if either of the above is incorrect (the second issue
discovered in the process of writing the test).
They all have a specific structure, so having them in the mess that
is functional_tests isn't really conducive to readability. More
importantly, functional_tests is so big it slows down compilation,
so even dropping a few hundred lines is a win.
Sources of the failure may be multiple in case of distributed watchtower
deployment. In either case, the channel manager must return a final
update asking to its channel monitor(s) to broadcast the lastest state
available. Revocation secret must not be released for the faultive
channel.
In the future, we may return wider type of failures to take more
fine-grained processing decision (e.g if local disk failure and
redudant remote channel copy available channel may still be processed
forward).
Watchower Alice receives block 134, broadcasts state X, rejects state Y.
Watchtower Bob accepts state Y, receives blocks 135, broadcasts state Y.
State Y confirms onchain. Alice must be able to claim outputs.
With a distrbuted watchtowers deployment, where each monitor is plugged
to its own chain view, there is no guarantee that block are going to be
seen in same order. Watchtower may diverge in their acceptance of a
submitted `commitment_signed` update due to a block timing-out a HTLC
and provoking a subset but yet not seen by the other watchtower subset.
Any update reject by one of the watchtower must block offchain coordinator
to move channel state forward and release revocation secret for previous
state.
In this case, we want any watchtower from the rejection subset to still
be able to claim outputs if the concurrent state, has accepted by the
other subset, is confirming. This improve overall watchtower system
fault-tolerance.
This change stores local commitment transaction unconditionally and fail
the update if there is knowledge of an already signed commitment
transaction (ChannelMonitor.local_tx_signed=true).
