lnrpc+autopilot: add graph diameter calculation

* adds a brute force computation of the diameter
* adds a more efficient calculation of the diameter
This commit is contained in:
bitromortac 2021-12-22 11:03:03 +01:00
parent 4d9a05c2f4
commit 52d56a8990
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: 1965063FC13BEBE2
4 changed files with 273 additions and 2 deletions

View File

@ -1,5 +1,12 @@
package autopilot
// diameterCutoff is used to discard nodes in the diameter calculation.
// It is the multiplier for the eccentricity of the highest-degree node,
// serving as a cutoff to discard all nodes with a smaller hop distance. This
// number should not be set close to 1 and is a tradeoff for computation cost,
// where 0 is maximally costly.
const diameterCutoff = 0.75
// SimpleGraph stores a simplifed adj graph of a channel graph to speed
// up graph processing by eliminating all unnecessary hashing and map access.
type SimpleGraph struct {
@ -62,5 +69,162 @@ func NewSimpleGraph(g ChannelGraph) (*SimpleGraph, error) {
graph.Nodes[nodeIndex] = nodeID
}
// We prepare to give some debug output about the size of the graph.
totalChannels := 0
for _, channels := range graph.Adj {
totalChannels += len(channels)
}
// The number of channels is double counted, so divide by two.
log.Debugf("Initialized simple graph with %d nodes and %d "+
"channels", len(graph.Adj), totalChannels/2)
return graph, nil
}
// maxVal is a helper function to get the maximal value of all values of a map.
func maxVal(mapping map[int]uint32) uint32 {
maxValue := uint32(0)
for _, value := range mapping {
if maxValue < value {
maxValue = value
}
}
return maxValue
}
// degree determines the number of edges for a node in the graph.
func (graph *SimpleGraph) degree(node int) int {
return len(graph.Adj[node])
}
// nodeMaxDegree determines the node with the max degree and its degree.
func (graph *SimpleGraph) nodeMaxDegree() (int, int) {
var maxNode, maxDegree int
for node := range graph.Adj {
degree := graph.degree(node)
if degree > maxDegree {
maxNode = node
maxDegree = degree
}
}
return maxNode, maxDegree
}
// shortestPathLengths performs a breadth-first-search from a node to all other
// nodes, returning the lengths of the paths.
func (graph *SimpleGraph) shortestPathLengths(node int) map[int]uint32 {
// level indicates the shell of the search around the root node.
var level uint32
graphOrder := len(graph.Adj)
// nextLevel tracks which nodes should be visited in the next round.
nextLevel := make([]int, 0, graphOrder)
// The root node is put as a starting point for the exploration.
nextLevel = append(nextLevel, node)
// Seen tracks already visited nodes and tracks how far away they are.
seen := make(map[int]uint32, graphOrder)
// Mark the root node as seen.
seen[node] = level
// thisLevel contains the nodes that are explored in the round.
thisLevel := make([]int, 0, graphOrder)
// We discover other nodes in a ring-like structure as long as we don't
// have more nodes to explore.
for len(nextLevel) > 0 {
level++
// We swap the queues for efficient memory management.
thisLevel, nextLevel = nextLevel, thisLevel
// Visit all neighboring nodes of the level and mark them as
// seen if they were not discovered before.
for _, thisNode := range thisLevel {
for _, neighbor := range graph.Adj[thisNode] {
_, ok := seen[neighbor]
if !ok {
nextLevel = append(nextLevel, neighbor)
seen[neighbor] = level
}
// If we have seen all nodes, we return early.
if len(seen) == graphOrder {
return seen
}
}
}
// Empty the queue to be used in the next level.
thisLevel = thisLevel[:0:cap(thisLevel)]
}
return seen
}
// nodeEccentricity calculates the eccentricity (longest shortest path to all
// other nodes) of a node.
func (graph *SimpleGraph) nodeEccentricity(node int) uint32 {
pathLengths := graph.shortestPathLengths(node)
return maxVal(pathLengths)
}
// nodeEccentricities calculates the eccentricities for the given nodes.
func (graph *SimpleGraph) nodeEccentricities(nodes []int) map[int]uint32 {
eccentricities := make(map[int]uint32, len(graph.Adj))
for _, node := range nodes {
eccentricities[node] = graph.nodeEccentricity(node)
}
return eccentricities
}
// Diameter returns the maximal eccentricity (longest shortest path
// between any node pair) in the graph.
//
// Note: This method is exact but expensive, use DiameterRadialCutoff instead.
func (graph *SimpleGraph) Diameter() uint32 {
nodes := make([]int, len(graph.Adj))
for a := range nodes {
nodes[a] = a
}
eccentricities := graph.nodeEccentricities(nodes)
return maxVal(eccentricities)
}
// DiameterRadialCutoff is a method to efficiently evaluate the diameter of a
// graph. The highest-degree node is usually central in the graph. We can
// determine its eccentricity (shortest-longest path length to any other node)
// and use it as an approximation for the radius of the network. We then
// use this radius to compute a cutoff. All the nodes within a distance of the
// cutoff are discarded, as they represent the inside of the graph. We then
// loop over all outer nodes and determine their eccentricities, from which we
// get the diameter.
func (graph *SimpleGraph) DiameterRadialCutoff() uint32 {
// Determine the reference node as the node with the highest degree.
nodeMaxDegree, _ := graph.nodeMaxDegree()
distances := graph.shortestPathLengths(nodeMaxDegree)
eccentricityMaxDegreeNode := maxVal(distances)
// We use the eccentricity to define a cutoff for the interior of the
// graph from the reference node.
cutoff := uint32(float32(eccentricityMaxDegreeNode) * diameterCutoff)
log.Debugf("Cutoff radius is %d hops (max-degree node's "+
"eccentricity is %d)", cutoff, eccentricityMaxDegreeNode)
// Remove the nodes that are close to the reference node.
var nodes []int
for node, distance := range distances {
if distance > cutoff {
nodes = append(nodes, node)
}
}
log.Debugf("Evaluated nodes: %d, discarded nodes %d",
len(nodes), len(graph.Adj)-len(nodes))
// Compute the diameter of the remaining nodes.
eccentricities := graph.nodeEccentricities(nodes)
return maxVal(eccentricities)
}

View File

@ -0,0 +1,94 @@
package autopilot
import (
"testing"
"github.com/stretchr/testify/require"
)
var (
testShortestPathLengths = map[int]uint32{
0: 0,
1: 1,
2: 1,
3: 1,
4: 2,
5: 2,
6: 3,
7: 3,
8: 4,
}
testNodeEccentricities = map[int]uint32{
0: 4,
1: 5,
2: 4,
3: 3,
4: 3,
5: 3,
6: 4,
7: 4,
8: 5,
}
)
// NewTestSimpleGraph is a helper that generates a SimpleGraph from a test
// graph description.
// Assumes that the graph description is internally consistent, i.e. edges are
// not repeatedly defined.
func NewTestSimpleGraph(graph testGraphDesc) SimpleGraph {
// We convert the test graph description into an adjacency list.
adjList := make([][]int, graph.nodes)
for node, neighbors := range graph.edges {
for _, neighbor := range neighbors {
adjList[node] = append(adjList[node], neighbor)
adjList[neighbor] = append(adjList[neighbor], node)
}
}
return SimpleGraph{Adj: adjList}
}
func TestShortestPathLengths(t *testing.T) {
simpleGraph := NewTestSimpleGraph(centralityTestGraph)
// Test the shortest path lengths from node 0 to all other nodes.
shortestPathLengths := simpleGraph.shortestPathLengths(0)
require.Equal(t, shortestPathLengths, testShortestPathLengths)
}
func TestEccentricities(t *testing.T) {
simpleGraph := NewTestSimpleGraph(centralityTestGraph)
// Test the node eccentricities for all nodes.
nodes := make([]int, len(simpleGraph.Adj))
for a := range nodes {
nodes[a] = a
}
nodeEccentricities := simpleGraph.nodeEccentricities(nodes)
require.Equal(t, nodeEccentricities, testNodeEccentricities)
}
func TestDiameterExact(t *testing.T) {
simpleGraph := NewTestSimpleGraph(centralityTestGraph)
// Test the diameter in a brute-force manner.
diameter := simpleGraph.Diameter()
require.Equal(t, uint32(5), diameter)
}
func TestDiameterCutoff(t *testing.T) {
simpleGraph := NewTestSimpleGraph(centralityTestGraph)
// Test the diameter by cutting out the inside of the graph.
diameter := simpleGraph.DiameterRadialCutoff()
require.Equal(t, uint32(5), diameter)
}
func BenchmarkShortestPathOpt(b *testing.B) {
// TODO: a method that generates a huge graph is needed
simpleGraph := NewTestSimpleGraph(centralityTestGraph)
for n := 0; n < b.N; n++ {
_ = simpleGraph.shortestPathLengths(0)
}
}

View File

@ -75,6 +75,8 @@
`remote_balance`](https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/pull/5931) in
`pending_force_closing_channels` under `pendingchannels` whereas before was
empty(zero).
* The graph's [diameter is calculated](https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/pull/6066)
and added to the `getnetworkinfo` output.
* [Add dev only RPC subserver and the devrpc.ImportGraph
call](https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/pull/6149)
@ -131,6 +133,7 @@ gRPC performance metrics (latency to process `GetInfo`, etc)](https://github.com
* 3nprob
* Andreas Schjønhaug
* asvdf
* bitromortac
* BTCparadigm
* Carla Kirk-Cohen
* Carsten Otto
@ -151,4 +154,4 @@ gRPC performance metrics (latency to process `GetInfo`, etc)](https://github.com
* Thebora Kompanioni
* Torkel Rogstad
* Vsevolod Kaganovych
* Yong Yu
* Yong Yu

View File

@ -5904,10 +5904,20 @@ func (r *rpcServer) GetNetworkInfo(ctx context.Context,
minChannelSize = 0
}
// TODO(roasbeef): graph diameter
// Graph diameter.
channelGraph := autopilot.ChannelGraphFromDatabase(graph)
simpleGraph, err := autopilot.NewSimpleGraph(channelGraph)
if err != nil {
return nil, err
}
start := time.Now()
diameter := simpleGraph.DiameterRadialCutoff()
rpcsLog.Infof("elapsed time for diameter (%d) calculation: %v", diameter,
time.Since(start))
// TODO(roasbeef): also add oldest channel?
netInfo := &lnrpc.NetworkInfo{
GraphDiameter: diameter,
MaxOutDegree: maxChanOut,
AvgOutDegree: float64(2*numChannels) / float64(numNodes),
NumNodes: numNodes,